Case #47681 Work

My colleague presented my idea as hers in a meeting. Was I wrong to call it out there and then?

The jury has spoken.

14,625 jurors Β· 291 asked for more information

The complainant 81%
The colleague 5%
Both 13%
Neither 1%

Top jury comment

'Happy to share the full document' is the most professional mic drop I've ever heard.

2,100 agree

Read all 6 comments

Verdicts are the opinions of people who voted here, based on one side's account. The majority is not always right.

Read the case

The complainant says

I shared a detailed idea for improving our onboarding process with a colleague over lunch, including a rough document I'd written. Two days later, in a team meeting with our manager and a director, she presented it as 'something I've been thinking about'. Same structure, same examples, even the same name for it.

I said, in front of everyone, 'That's great, it's the proposal I sent you on Tuesday, happy to share the full document.' It went very quiet. Afterwards she told me I'd humiliated her and that she was going to credit me later.

The other side says the colleague, as the complainant tells it

She says she was building on my idea, not stealing it, and intended to mention me once the director had reacted. She says a professional would have raised it privately rather than embarrassing a colleague in front of senior people.

Deliver your own verdict

Jury discussion (6 comments)

Deliver your verdict to join the deliberation. Back to the case.

  1. Juror 2591 Voted: The complainant

    'Happy to share the full document' is the most professional mic drop I've ever heard.

    2,100 Agree 1,300 Funny 5 Hmm
  2. Juror 9972 Voted: The complainant

    Intended to credit you later. Sure. Later, as in never.

    1,500 Agree 400 Funny 6 Hmm
  3. Juror 5829 Voted: The complainant

    If you'd raised it privately afterwards, the director would already have associated the idea with her. You did it the only way that works.

    1,200 Agree 5 Funny 10 Hmm
    1. Juror 4210 Voted: The complainant

      Exactly. Credit is decided in the room.

      540 Agree 2 Funny 3 Hmm
  4. Juror 3496 Voted: The complainant

    She humiliated herself. You just said a true sentence politely.

    990 Agree 90 Funny 2 Hmm
  5. Juror 5115 Voted: The complainant

    You did nothing wrong but I'd still email your manager the original document with a timestamp. Paper trail.

    860 Agree 3 Funny 8 Hmm

Comment on the dispute, not the people. No names, guesses about who anyone is, or abuse. Jury room rules.

Report this case
What is wrong with it?

Part of Work. Submitted 47 days ago. Verdicts show what the people who voted here think, based on one side's account. The majority is not necessarily right, and nobody in this case should be identifiable. If you recognise yourself or someone else, please tell us.

More work cases

View all