Case #18587 Family 16,760 jurors so far

My brother ate the leftovers I'd saved. Who's wrong?

The complainant says

I'm staying at my parents' house for a few weeks between flats. My brother lives there too. On Sunday mum made a roast and I saved a plate for my Monday lunch: beef, roast potatoes, the lot. I wrapped it in foil, put it on the top shelf and wrote 'saved for Monday, do not eat' on a sticky note on the foil.

On Monday morning the plate was in the sink. My brother had come home late after the pub and eaten the whole thing. He says the sticky note had fallen off, but I found it stuck to the fridge door.

The other side says the brother, as the complainant tells it

He says he genuinely didn't see a note, he was hungry, and food in mum's fridge is fair game for anyone in the house. He's offered to buy me a meal deal as compensation.

Whose side are you on?

Skip to the verdict

Jury discussion (7 comments)

Deliver your verdict to join the deliberation. Back to the case.

  1. Juror 1161 Voted: The complainant

    A meal deal for a roast dinner plate is an insult to your mum.

    2,300 Agree 1,500 Funny 5 Hmm
  2. Juror 8542 Voted: The complainant

    The note was found stuck to the fridge door. It didn't fall off, it was relocated.

    1,900 Agree 1,800 Funny 8 Hmm
    1. Juror 6923 Voted: The complainant

      Evidence tampering at the family fridge.

      700 Agree 1,000 Funny 3 Hmm
    2. Juror 5304 Voted: The complainant

      The jury will disregard the meal deal.

      400 Agree 650 Funny 2 Hmm
  3. Juror 7637 Voted: The brother

    Coming home from the pub and eating a wrapped plate is how every brother on earth operates, sorry.

    720 Agree 900 Funny 10 Hmm
  4. Juror 4399 Voted: The complainant

    Make him cook the next roast. Full roast. With gravy made from scratch.

    1,000 Agree 300 Funny 2 Hmm
  5. Juror 6018 Voted: The complainant

    Foil plus top shelf plus a note. You did everything short of a padlock.

    860 Agree 100 Funny 3 Hmm

Comment on the dispute, not the people. No names, guesses about who anyone is, or abuse. Jury room rules.

Report this case
What is wrong with it?

Part of Family. Submitted 39 days ago. Verdicts show what the people who voted here think, based on one side's account. The majority is not necessarily right, and nobody in this case should be identifiable. If you recognise yourself or someone else, please tell us.

More family cases

View all