Real people. Real disputes.

Present your case.

Let strangers decide who's right.

Read both sides. Deliver your verdict. See who the jury sided with. 680,364 verdicts delivered.

Cases being judged

View all

Judge a case now

Case #71058 Everyday life 10,048 jurors so far

Should you give up your seat on the train if you've booked it and someone asks?

The complainant says

I booked a forward-facing window seat on a busy three-hour train journey, two weeks in advance, because I get motion sick facing backwards. A woman got on with her teenage son and asked me to swap to a seat further down the carriage so they could sit together.

The other seat was backwards-facing and in the middle. I explained about the motion sickness and politely said no. She said I was being unkind and several people looked at me.

The other side says the other passenger, as the complainant tells it

She says she booked late because of a family emergency and just wanted to sit with her son. She thinks most people would swap to help a parent.

Whose side are you on?

Skip to the verdict

Closest verdicts

View all

Most divisive

View all

New cases

View all

Browse by category

All cases

Got a dispute that needs settling?

Explain what happened, add the other side if you are feeling fair, and let strangers decide. No account needed.

Tell the story. Don't identify the people.

Submit a case