The docket

Most divisive

Cases where the jury is scattered across every verdict. Nobody can agree, so you decide.

Case #93045 Weddings

Should the bride's family pay for the whole wedding in this day and age?

7,684 jurors

Sided with Parents
74%

Sided with Future in-laws
26%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should the bride's family pay for the whole wedding in this day and age?
Case #65179 Weddings

I wore white to a wedding by accident. How bad is it?

9,154 jurors

Sided with Complainant
52%

Sided with Bride
48%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : I wore white to a wedding by accident. How bad is it?
Case #16464 Work

Who's wrong: me for eating fish at my desk, or my colleague for complaining to our manager?

10,220 jurors

Sided with Complainant
54%

Sided with Colleague
46%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Who's wrong: me for eating fish at my desk, or my colleague for complaining to our manager?
Case #28587 Flatmates

Should I have to pay for a cleaner I never wanted?

8,024 jurors

Sided with Complainant
44%

Sided with Flatmates
56%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should I have to pay for a cleaner I never wanted?
Case #29965 Relationships

Is it fair for my partner to want the bedroom at 17 degrees?

6,373 jurors

Sided with Complainant
59%

Sided with Partner
41%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it fair for my partner to want the bedroom at 17 degrees?
Case #26751 Money

Was I wrong to charge my brother interest on a loan?

9,023 jurors

Sided with Complainant
52%

Sided with Brother
48%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Was I wrong to charge my brother interest on a loan?
Case #68183 Friendship

My friend asked me to be her plus-one and then made me pay for the hotel. Who's wrong?

6,950 jurors

Sided with Complainant
60%

Sided with Friend
40%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My friend asked me to be her plus-one and then made me pay for the hotel. Who's wrong?
Case #85245 Weddings

My sister wants to bring her new baby to my child-free wedding. Am I wrong to say no?

17,231 jurors

Sided with Complainant
64%

Sided with Sister
36%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My sister wants to bring her new baby to my child-free wedding. Am I wrong to say no?
Case #63524 Money

Is it fair to ask my housemate to pay more because she has the bigger room?

9,928 jurors

Sided with Complainant
57%

Sided with Housemate
43%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it fair to ask my housemate to pay more because she has the bigger room?
Case #94757 Weddings

My friend didn't invite my partner of four years to her wedding. Should I still go?

8,721 jurors

Sided with Complainant
68%

Sided with Friend
32%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My friend didn't invite my partner of four years to her wedding. Should I still go?
Case #85454 Relationships

Was I wrong to read the last chapter of the book my partner and I were reading together?

4,347 jurors

Sided with Complainant
22%

Sided with Partner
78%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Was I wrong to read the last chapter of the book my partner and I were reading together?
Case #10721 Neighbours

Should I have told my neighbour her cat keeps coming into my house?

7,366 jurors

Sided with Complainant
32%

Sided with Neighbour
68%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should I have told my neighbour her cat keeps coming into my house?
Case #52178 Neighbours

My neighbour wants me to cut down my hedge because it blocks her light. Do I have to?

5,620 jurors

Sided with Complainant
69%

Sided with Neighbour
31%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My neighbour wants me to cut down my hedge because it blocks her light. Do I have to?
Case #78828 Work

My new starter wears headphones all day. Am I wrong to ask him to take them off?

6,574 jurors

Sided with Complainant
30%

Sided with New starter
70%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My new starter wears headphones all day. Am I wrong to ask him to take them off?
Case #97565 Weddings

Should guests be expected to pay for their own drinks at a wedding?

11,878 jurors

Sided with Complainant
44%

Sided with Cousin
56%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should guests be expected to pay for their own drinks at a wedding?
Case #48819 Relationships

Should my partner come to my work Christmas party even though they hate it?

5,444 jurors

Sided with Complainant
69%

Sided with Partner
31%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should my partner come to my work Christmas party even though they hate it?
Case #79234 Neighbours

My neighbour keeps taking in my parcels and then going away for the weekend.

5,255 jurors

Sided with Complainant
71%

Sided with Neighbour
29%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My neighbour keeps taking in my parcels and then going away for the weekend.
Case #20628 Everyday life

Is it rude to recline your seat on a short-haul flight?

12,431 jurors

Sided with Complainant
64%

Sided with Passenger behind
36%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it rude to recline your seat on a short-haul flight?
Case #51256 Neighbours

Were we wrong to complain about our neighbours' weekly garden parties?

8,622 jurors

Sided with Complainant
70%

Sided with Neighbours
30%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Were we wrong to complain about our neighbours' weekly garden parties?
Case #55995 Flatmates

Is it rude to ask a flatmate to stop singing in the shower at 6am?

6,204 jurors

Sided with Complainant
72%

Sided with Flatmate
28%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it rude to ask a flatmate to stop singing in the shower at 6am?
Case #10360 Flatmates

My flatmate wants the heating on 24/7 and split the bill equally. Fair?

7,233 jurors

Sided with Complainant
72%

Sided with Flatmate
28%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My flatmate wants the heating on 24/7 and split the bill equally. Fair?
Case #53454 Neighbours

Is it unreasonable to ask my neighbour to stop mowing at 8am on Sundays?

6,999 jurors

Sided with Complainant
66%

Sided with Neighbour
34%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it unreasonable to ask my neighbour to stop mowing at 8am on Sundays?
Case #65471 Relationships

My partner says I spend too much on coffee. Who's being unreasonable?

7,790 jurors

Sided with Complainant
72%

Sided with Partner
28%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My partner says I spend too much on coffee. Who's being unreasonable?
Case #27008 Everyday life

Who should get the last parking space: the car waiting with its indicator on, or me?

7,891 jurors

Sided with Complainant
73%

Sided with Other driver
27%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Who should get the last parking space: the car waiting with its indicator on, or me?
Case #60387 Friendship

My friend didn't invite me to her birthday but posted photos. Should I say something?

7,540 jurors

Sided with Complainant
79%

Sided with Friend
21%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My friend didn't invite me to her birthday but posted photos. Should I say something?
Case #62956 Neighbours

My neighbour parks across my driveway 'for five minutes' every morning. Am I wrong to block him in?

13,241 jurors

Sided with Complainant
79%

Sided with Neighbour
21%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My neighbour parks across my driveway 'for five minutes' every morning. Am I wrong to block him in?
Case #18223 Friendship

I cancelled dinner because my friend was 45 minutes late. Fair?

18,033 jurors

Sided with Complainant
80%

Sided with Friend
20%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : I cancelled dinner because my friend was 45 minutes late. Fair?
Case #15144 Flatmates

Am I unreasonable for moving my flatmate's dirty dishes into their room?

18,536 jurors

Sided with Complainant
82%

Sided with Flatmate
18%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Am I unreasonable for moving my flatmate's dirty dishes into their room?
Case #76563 Family

Should my sister have to pay rent to live with our dad?

8,649 jurors

Sided with Complainant
85%

Sided with Sister
15%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should my sister have to pay rent to live with our dad?
Case #55114 Relationships

My partner wants to keep our finances completely separate. Unreasonable?

10,548 jurors

Sided with Complainant
84%

Sided with Partner
16%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My partner wants to keep our finances completely separate. Unreasonable?
Case #39004 Relationships

My partner booked a holiday with his mates on our anniversary. Am I overreacting?

10,028 jurors

Sided with Complainant
86%

Sided with Partner
14%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My partner booked a holiday with his mates on our anniversary. Am I overreacting?
Case #42835 Money

I stopped tipping at restaurants with a service charge already added. Tight or reasonable?

8,167 jurors

Sided with Complainant
78%

Sided with Friend
22%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : I stopped tipping at restaurants with a service charge already added. Tight or reasonable?
Case #59629 Money

Should I split petrol costs with a colleague when I'm already driving past her house?

6,031 jurors

Sided with Complainant
16%

Sided with Colleague
84%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should I split petrol costs with a colleague when I'm already driving past her house?
Case #80131 Relationships

Is it unreasonable to expect my partner to put their phone away at dinner?

6,855 jurors

Sided with Complainant
86%

Sided with Partner
14%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it unreasonable to expect my partner to put their phone away at dinner?
Case #56315 Flatmates

Was I wrong to label my food in the shared fridge?

9,380 jurors

Sided with Complainant
89%

Sided with Other housemates
11%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Was I wrong to label my food in the shared fridge?
Case #16625 Family

My dad wants me to take the family dog when I move out. Do I have to?

7,304 jurors

Sided with Complainant
88%

Sided with Dad
12%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My dad wants me to take the family dog when I move out. Do I have to?
Case #45095 Money

My friend expects me to pay her back for a gift I never asked for. Who's right?

7,025 jurors

Sided with Complainant
85%

Sided with Friend
15%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My friend expects me to pay her back for a gift I never asked for. Who's right?
Case #37282 Everyday life

My friend and I disagree about who gets the last slice of pizza. Help.

14,984 jurors · closed

Sided with Complainant
88%

Sided with Friend
12%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
See the verdict : My friend and I disagree about who gets the last slice of pizza. Help.
Case #19052 Flatmates

Should my flatmate's boyfriend be paying towards the bills?

12,536 jurors

Sided with Complainant
88%

Sided with Flatmate
12%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should my flatmate's boyfriend be paying towards the bills?
Case #37153 Neighbours

The neighbours' tree drops fruit into my garden. Can I keep the apples?

6,738 jurors

Sided with Complainant
90%

Sided with Neighbour
10%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : The neighbours' tree drops fruit into my garden. Can I keep the apples?
Case #47515 Friendship

Should I tell my friend her business idea is bad before she quits her job?

7,286 jurors · closed

Sided with Complainant
92%

Sided with Friend
8%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
See the verdict : Should I tell my friend her business idea is bad before she quits her job?
Case #20716 Work

My coworker keeps booking the only meeting room for 'focus time'. Fair?

5,921 jurors

Sided with Complainant
90%

Sided with Coworker
10%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My coworker keeps booking the only meeting room for 'focus time'. Fair?
Case #39186 Family

My mum keeps rearranging my kitchen when she visits. Can I ask her to stop?

7,984 jurors

Sided with Complainant
93%

Sided with Mum
7%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My mum keeps rearranging my kitchen when she visits. Can I ask her to stop?
Case #20288 Friendship

Is it rude to leave a group chat that's 90% memes?

5,674 jurors

Sided with Complainant
93%

Sided with Group chat
7%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it rude to leave a group chat that's 90% memes?
Case #75913 Flatmates

Who should pay for the broken TV?

16,030 jurors

Sided with Complainant
93%

Sided with Flatmate
7%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Who should pay for the broken TV?
Case #66162 Family

My parents lent me my house deposit and now want a say in the kitchen. Fair?

6,894 jurors

Sided with Complainant
92%

Sided with Parents
8%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My parents lent me my house deposit and now want a say in the kitchen. Fair?
Case #57810 Weddings

My friend wants me to use my holiday allowance for a three-day hen do abroad. Can I skip part of it?

13,808 jurors

Sided with Complainant
92%

Sided with Bride
8%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My friend wants me to use my holiday allowance for a three-day hen do abroad. Can I skip part of it?
Case #47681 Work

My colleague presented my idea as hers in a meeting. Was I wrong to call it out there and then?

14,625 jurors

Sided with Complainant
94%

Sided with Colleague
6%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My colleague presented my idea as hers in a meeting. Was I wrong to call it out there and then?
Case #13322 Friendship

My best friend keeps bringing her new partner to our girls' nights. Can I say no?

8,214 jurors

Sided with Complainant
94%

Sided with Best friend
6%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My best friend keeps bringing her new partner to our girls' nights. Can I say no?
Case #92504 Everyday life

Is it okay to ask a stranger to stop playing videos out loud on the bus?

8,432 jurors

Sided with Complainant
96%

Sided with Other passenger
4%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it okay to ask a stranger to stop playing videos out loud on the bus?
Case #71058 Everyday life

Should you give up your seat on the train if you've booked it and someone asks?

10,048 jurors

Sided with Complainant
93%

Sided with Other passenger
7%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should you give up your seat on the train if you've booked it and someone asks?
Case #61893 Flatmates

My flatmate put up a camera in the hallway 'for parcels'. Am I overreacting?

11,102 jurors

Sided with Complainant
94%

Sided with Flatmate
6%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My flatmate put up a camera in the hallway 'for parcels'. Am I overreacting?
Case #73808 Work

My manager messages me on WhatsApp at 10pm. Can I just ignore it?

12,639 jurors

Sided with Complainant
95%

Sided with Manager
5%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My manager messages me on WhatsApp at 10pm. Can I just ignore it?
Case #18587 Family

My brother ate the leftovers I'd saved. Who's wrong?

16,760 jurors

Sided with Complainant
93%

Sided with Brother
7%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My brother ate the leftovers I'd saved. Who's wrong?
Case #81719 Weddings

Was the best man's speech too much, or am I too sensitive?

14,990 jurors

Sided with Complainant
94%

Sided with Best man
6%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Was the best man's speech too much, or am I too sensitive?
Case #95705 Neighbours

My neighbours want me to pay half for a new fence. I didn't want a new fence.

9,202 jurors

Sided with Complainant
94%

Sided with Neighbours
6%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : My neighbours want me to pay half for a new fence. I didn't want a new fence.
Case #96669 Work

Is it okay to skip the team building day because it's on a Saturday?

9,914 jurors

Sided with Complainant
95%

Sided with Employer
5%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Is it okay to skip the team building day because it's on a Saturday?
Case #31410 Family

Was it wrong to tell my kids the truth about the tooth fairy when my in-laws asked me not to?

6,300 jurors

Sided with Complainant
95%

Sided with In-laws
5%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Was it wrong to tell my kids the truth about the tooth fairy when my in-laws asked me not to?
Case #60086 Work

I refused to cover my colleague's shifts for the third weekend in a row. Selfish?

7,382 jurors

Sided with Complainant
95%

Sided with Colleague
5%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : I refused to cover my colleague's shifts for the third weekend in a row. Selfish?
Case #46102 Money

Should we split the restaurant bill equally when I only had a starter?

16,340 jurors

Sided with Complainant
95%

Sided with Rest of the group
5%

Both and Neither votes are left out.
Judge this case : Should we split the restaurant bill equally when I only had a starter?